The Biggest Questions About AI
The map · 4 Power · 4.1 Regulatory design · 4.1.1

Regulatory object

Should rules attach to compute, training runs, model capabilities, weights, developers, deployers, applications, or resulting harms?

Compute is the most governable input — quantifiable, excludable, produced by a concentrated supply chain — but capability maps poorly onto FLOP counts, and application-layer rules miss the frontier entirely.

View on the map → · Open in Browse →

What changed
February–August 2026 · swept August 3, 2026 · editorial review pending
01

The United States began answering the question in drafts: the bipartisan Great American AI Act would attach rules to large frontier developers — an authorized standards center, third-party verifiers, SB 53-style transparency — in exchange for preemption, and the state laws it would preempt already converge on the same object: developers defined by compute-plus-revenue triggers. The counterargument gained precision too: rules attached to models or weights don't survive replication, so regulate use at deployment choke points.

Recent thinking
5 featured from 7 tracked · February–August 2026 · all 7 chronologically →
Shakeel Hashim, Veronica Irwin & Celia Ford · Transformer · 5 Jun 2026 news
The best AI bill yet may not get far
At 269 pages, GAAIA contains plenty of excellent stuff. It would formally authorize the Center for AI Standards and Innovation with a $100m annual budget.

The definitive early read on the bipartisan Great American AI Act — the first serious federal answer to the regulatory-object question: attach rules to frontier developers via an authorized CAISI, third-party verification organizations, and SB 53-style transparency, traded against preemption.

Justine Gluck · Future of Privacy Forum · 9 Jun 2026 essay
Frontier AI Goes Federal: How the Great American AI Act Compares to State Laws
The draft's frontier model provisions are not starting from scratch. They closely track the framework emerging from California's SB 53, New York's RAISE Act, and Illinois' SB 315.

Side-by-side of the federal draft against SB 53, RAISE, and Illinois SB 315, showing a de facto US regulatory object — large frontier developers defined by compute-plus-revenue triggers — crystallizing from state templates.

Zvi Mowshowitz · Don't Worry About the Vase · 5 Jun 2026 essay
OpenAI Offers A New Policy Blueprint
Implementation details matter a lot, but this document exceeds expectations a lot.

Close reading of OpenAI's federal policy blueprint — developer-level obligations overseen by CAISI in exchange for preemption — arguing it could be the 'minimum viable deal' on what rules attach to, while flagging the accountability gaps such a bargain must close.

John deVadoss · IEEE Spectrum · 2 Feb 2026 essay
Don't Regulate AI Models. Regulate AI Use
Model weights and code are digital artifacts; once released, by a lab, a leak, or a foreign competitor, they replicate at near-zero cost.

A clean statement of the use-based position: model- and weights-attached rules are unenforceable once artifacts replicate, so regulation should bind at deployment choke points — the application-layer answer the framing warns misses the frontier.

Scott Babwah Brennen · TechPolicy.Press · 6 Jul 2026 essay
Where State AI Legislation Stands Half Way Into 2026
more than half of US states have together enacted more than 100 new AI laws this term

The best mid-2026 empirical map of what US states actually attach rules to — companion chatbots, data centers, insurance, dynamic pricing — showing application-layer objects dominating state practice even as frontier-developer frameworks spread.

Additional relevant discussion (2)
Congress must not waste the AI policy window — Shakeel Hashim, Celia Ford · Transformer (Shakeel Hashim) · 11 Sep 2026
Should we "pace" AI self-improvement? — Tim Fist, Saif M. Khan · Noahpinion (Noah Smith) · 9 Aug 2026
Foundational reading (2)Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging RisksAnderljung et al., GovAI · 2023Computing Power and the Governance of AISastry, Heim et al. · 2024
Next4.1.2 Thresholds